Super Bowl Gameday Thread

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Manning and Brady are both all time greats. This constant need to rank them is exhausting.

I think ranking any player at any position is silly because there are just to many variables at play. Rank RB's - well who had the better oline? Rank Wr's - well who had the better QB?
The more interesting question is if you were starting a franchise tomorrow which guy would you take? That way it is based solely on your eye test.