Grade Jason Campbell

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Sheriff Gonna Getcha

Also, Campbell's QB rating against TB was better than Brunell's 2006 QB rating.

Yay! An actual arguement! This makes GTripp happy.

I said they had similar games. The fallacy in QB rating is that it is reliant on TD passes. (It's why I've said time, and time again it's a bad stat) Jason Campbell ran an offense that scored 17 points on 2 TDs (and the D forced 2 turnovers, which is something that they haven't done this season, though I'm not sure it helped us score more points), and Brunell average's one TD a season. My steadfast belief is that since Brunell's offense averages 2 TD's a game, he shouldn't be penalized when Portis runs it in. But it does create a discrepancy in QB Rating.

But yeah, that's not to take away from Campbell's lofty QB rating from Sunday. Just to show how easily a QB rating of 93 and one of 85 can be showing the same thing.