Do you want the Redskins to win?

mike340 · 12-06-2006, 04:35 AM

I think the guy is asking a reasonable question in a calm manner.

If I understand it, he wants to win emotionally and cheers for the 'Skins, especially on game day, and he doesn't want them to "tank". He doesn't care about the playoffs because he feels we are not good enough this year to do anything meaningful if we got there.

Here's a related question:
If you could choose one of the following, which would it be?
1) The Redskins win the remaining games while playing badly, but winning because the other team was worse. (penalties, interceptions, bad calls, etc.)
2) The Redskins lose the remaining games while playing very well. (Campbell on the money, good D, etc, but the opposing team has "career" days, like when a basketball team shoots over 70% for a game.)

The first scenario puts more importance on the record this year. The second puts more emphasis on the possibilities for next year.

To revert to the question which originated this thread, I believe what he is trying to ask is:
If we were to look only at our final record (ignoring the emotional impact of winning or losing on game day) what would you prefer?
1) Finishing 8-8 (no playoffs)
2) Finishing 4-12
In the first scenario we have a better record this year, but next year we get a (much) worse draft pick (after an exchange with Denver.)
In the second we have a more embarrassing record, but we would get a very high draft pick (and probably too high to have to exchange with Denver.)

So I think he is asking which is more important to us: a better record this year (when we aren't going anywhere) or a better draft pick next year. A corresponding personnel question would be:
If we had a backup who is currently worse than our starter but could become better than our starter with some starts under his belt, should we keep playing the current starter to have a better record this year, or should we start the backup so we're better next year?
This is a reasonable question, and I think our coaching staff has shown its decision.

12-06-2006, 04:35 AM	#20
mike340 Special Teams Join Date: Jun 2006 Age: 69 Posts: 322	Re: Do you want the Redskins to win? I think the guy is asking a reasonable question in a calm manner. If I understand it, he wants to win emotionally and cheers for the 'Skins, especially on game day, and he doesn't want them to "tank". He doesn't care about the playoffs because he feels we are not good enough this year to do anything meaningful if we got there. Here's a related question: If you could choose one of the following, which would it be? 1) The Redskins win the remaining games while playing badly, but winning because the other team was worse. (penalties, interceptions, bad calls, etc.) 2) The Redskins lose the remaining games while playing very well. (Campbell on the money, good D, etc, but the opposing team has "career" days, like when a basketball team shoots over 70% for a game.) The first scenario puts more importance on the record this year. The second puts more emphasis on the possibilities for next year. To revert to the question which originated this thread, I believe what he is trying to ask is: If we were to look only at our final record (ignoring the emotional impact of winning or losing on game day) what would you prefer? 1) Finishing 8-8 (no playoffs) 2) Finishing 4-12 In the first scenario we have a better record this year, but next year we get a (much) worse draft pick (after an exchange with Denver.) In the second we have a more embarrassing record, but we would get a very high draft pick (and probably too high to have to exchange with Denver.) So I think he is asking which is more important to us: a better record this year (when we aren't going anywhere) or a better draft pick next year. A corresponding personnel question would be: If we had a backup who is currently worse than our starter but could become better than our starter with some starts under his belt, should we keep playing the current starter to have a better record this year, or should we start the backup so we're better next year? This is a reasonable question, and I think our coaching staff has shown its decision.

Do you want the Redskins to win?

Locker Room Main Forum