2007 Pro Football Hall of Fame Finalists

[irish]

Originally Posted by jsarno

1- Monk
2- Grimm
3- Dent
4- Matthews
5- Reed
6- D. Thomas
7- T. Thomas

Grimm might be the only one not as deserving, but of course I gave him the heart pick. Take away Grimm, I'd still vote for all 6 of them.

Irish...why would you not vote for Monk? He was THE best receiver in NFL history when he retired.

I think when you look at his numbers now they just dont look like HOF numbers. I know he held those records when he retired but its obvious they were not good enough for induction back when he was 1st eligible and now these many years later they just dont make it. Someone mentioned Andre Reed having numbers better than Monk. Well IMO there is no way AR is a HOFer so if he isnt then there is no way Monk can go in. Like I said, he was a very good receiver but just not quite HOF material.