Gun Restrictions and Your Rights

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

Since the state of Iraq's government is in complete disarray and there's no semblance of a police force to adequately address the problem of crime, I'd say this is a poor comparison to use.

You predict that, absent legal gun ownership, the streets of America would be unbelievably chaotic with death everywhere. As a corollary, you believe that the U.S. government is incapable of protecting the people by itself (i.e., it needs gun owners to assist). So, with regard to Iraq, I don't see how you can simply blame their ineffective government for the violence. After all, you already believe that our government is incapable of keeping us relatively safe.

Obviously, there are many other problems in Iraq (sectarian strife) that we do not have. So Iraq, of course, is not completely analogous. But, I don't think there is a single person who believes that the proliferation of weapons in Iraq has deterred criminals.

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

I will say that if guns were outlawed amongst the general public, there would still be crime, wouldn't you agree?

I certainly agree. But, I also think that gun crimes would decrease as the availability of guns decreases and their cost increases.