Jason Campbell vs. Eli Manning

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

You think Garcia is MILES above JC and Manning? Really????

No disrespect to Mr. Garcia. He has made a huge difference for TB. No question you can win with him if he is in the west coast offense. But he is not a top flight NFL QB. He can't take over a game. He can't put a team on his back and carry the team. That type of QB would be MILES above Manning and JC. I don't put him in that class.

Okay, so who are you crediting Tampa's 6-4 start to if not Garcia? If he hasn't taken over a game, who has?

7 and a half yards per attempt while completing 64% with 3 interceptions in 278 attempts is pretty much the definition of taking over the game...every game.

I don't deny that this could be Garcia's last season at the top of the game, but he's got Tampa poised to take their division despite a similar effort on defense from a 4-12 team last year, and his running back going out for the season over a month ago. He's doing even better this season than Favre is, IMO.