A Playoff question: Campbell or Collins?

[onlydarksets]

Originally Posted by GoSkins!

What??? Collins has put up better numbers than Campbell, can run the entire offensive play book, hasn't thrown an interception, and has won all three games he has been in. He is the best QB for right now. Campbell will probably become a better QB than Collins very soon, and there is no question he has more natural ability, but he still has some growing to do!

I'm not saying that Collins hasn't played lights out. I'm saying that each week is a new week, and a 100% healthy JC gives us the best chance in the long term to be successful. Momentum is a factor, but it's a short-term factor - consistency and security are the long term factors in winning. See canthetuna's posts for more on that (I agree with most of what he is saying about other reasons to start JC, even if he isn't the better QB).