For the Zorn / Campbell Excuse makers...

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Originally Posted by over the mountain

^^^ i dont think the argument for or against JC starts and stops with qb rating and number of sacks. by doing that you might be inviting someone to post JC's win-loss record (team thing but this stat gets attached to the qbs as we all know) or TDs hes thrown as a slam shut argument against anyone supporting JC.

im just going to put this in my sig: reasonable redskins fans can disagree with each other without one side being stupider than the other.

TDs thrown is included in the QB rating. I agree stats aren't everything, but they give you a pretty clear indication of trends. Interpretation of stats is important too. If JC had a 77.6 QB rating and was sacked only 1.31 time per game then it's a pretty logical conclusion to say if his QB rating is now 85.7 and he's being sacked 2.43 times per game he's gotten better.

As far as TDs this year he's thrown 13, the teams/QBs mentioned in the first post have thrown 15/15/14 behind better OLs with experienced OCs.

No one is calling anyone stupid, but to ignore facts and statisitics and call those that have facts and statistics to back them up and support Zorn/Campbell "excuse makers"....well, it is what it is.