A Grimm Fairy Tale

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Why not? He won a SB, the next year was NFL MVP and NFL offensive player of the year and let us to another SB and was in charge of team that set an all time NFL scoring record that has been broken twice since then. Not great stats but pretty good accomplishments.

Theismann was a very average QB from 76-81 and wasn't even a full time starter until 78. 82, 83 and 84 were his prime years and his only truly great year was 83. In 85 his last year he was playing awful before he broke his leg. I remember the town was really on Gibbs to bench him that last year. No way is Theismann a HOF QB. Not even close.