The Collins Sighting

mike340 · 10-19-2009, 01:13 PM

You need to find out how much is on JC and how much is on the rest of the offense. For that reason I voted for starting Collins. Two years ago we had no wide receiver production until Campbell went out and Collins came in. On the few occasions when Moss has been open JC has almost invariably missed him. When I watched "game breaks" I saw that it was almost always passes where the wide receiver had to "make" the play. JC appears as though he thinks that it's all on his pass, so he never allows the receiver time to make a play.
We need to find out if JC is salvagable. It appears that the season is unsalvagable with JC at the helm, and probably with anybody at the QB position. So I don't see the harm in starting Todd Collins. At least we'll get a chance to make a comparison, and JC might do better as a sub since the defense will be preparing for Collins.

As an aside, as well as the defense played yesterday, I was very bummed that the moment we took the lead they allowed them to tie it (on an invisible drive yet!)

Here's to the offense finding a way to score points, even if they have to put the cheerleaders on the offensive line!

View Poll Results: Who should be the Redskins starting QB next week?
Collins	39	42.39%
Campbell	53	57.61%
Voters: 92. You may not vote on this poll

10-19-2009, 01:13 PM	#29
mike340 Special Teams Join Date: Jun 2006 Age: 69 Posts: 322	Re: The Collins Sighting You need to find out how much is on JC and how much is on the rest of the offense. For that reason I voted for starting Collins. Two years ago we had no wide receiver production until Campbell went out and Collins came in. On the few occasions when Moss has been open JC has almost invariably missed him. When I watched "game breaks" I saw that it was almost always passes where the wide receiver had to "make" the play. JC appears as though he thinks that it's all on his pass, so he never allows the receiver time to make a play. We need to find out if JC is salvagable. It appears that the season is unsalvagable with JC at the helm, and probably with anybody at the QB position. So I don't see the harm in starting Todd Collins. At least we'll get a chance to make a comparison, and JC might do better as a sub since the defense will be preparing for Collins. As an aside, as well as the defense played yesterday, I was very bummed that the moment we took the lead they allowed them to tie it (on an invisible drive yet!) Here's to the offense finding a way to score points, even if they have to put the cheerleaders on the offensive line!

The Collins Sighting

Locker Room Main Forum