nfl week 15

[12thMan]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

Ok, let me get this straight. Your stating that just because Roy Williams made one pro bowl doesn't make him than Myles Austin. Utilizing your logic I'll counter with the same argument. Just because Myles had ONE season better than Roy doesn't mean he's better. -

I think that's a pretty sound argument. One Pro Bowl doesn't make Roy Williams better than Austin. Santana Moss has more Pro Bowls than Devin Thomas, but I think Devin is emerging as our number one. Chris Cooley has more than Fred Davis, but anyone watching Davis play this season knows this kid is going to be a stud. It's just a matter of time before he makes a trip to the Pro Bowl. Yes, I'm calling it.

If Roy is better, how come his numbers don't back it up? And when Calvin Johnson and Roy had the same QB throwing to them, Calvin emerged as the number one reciever there. We can play with the numbers all we want, but the simple fact is Roy Williams has 36 catches after tonight. And those numbers are more in line with the type of receiver he really is.