2012 redskins

[Shadowbyte]

Originally Posted by tmandoug1

Did you see any of the games that "DM5" played for the Redskins or are you to busy being tooting his horn. Missed reads, dirt balls and plain old crappy passes and that stupid ass grin when he blew a pass, please do not come on here and tout D Mcnabb, he sucked in Philly and he sucked in DC, that was all proven by his performance in the first game as a Viking with a total of 39 yards passing. You must realize that he is not a finisher and I do not care what gameplan he was in or wanted he was not accurate enough in the long run to be an elite QB. Get off his johnson dude really.

Yes I watched the games where DM5 beat the 2 teams that represented the NFC in the championship game last year. Also, can you please tell me who was the last QB to pass for over 3200 for the Redskins? I'll help you out since you're unaware of the facts. It was Gus Ferotte who passed for 3,453 yards in 1996 who started all 16 games. Only 76 more yards than DM5 who only started 12 for us.

So I don't what measuring stick you're using to make your points, emotional assessments don't qualify as facts. The fact of the matter is he's outplayed every QB who's been here since Mark Rypien. Even in Brunells and Ferotte's best years here, they both only completed 57% of their passes. Even Rypiens phenomenal year in 1991 he only completed 59% of his passes, one percent higher than DM5's 58% in 2010. So when you say he's so inaccurate, that's more of an emotional statement than a factual statement. Emotions carry no weight when we're debating the facts.