Redskins Add WRs Pierre Garcon and Joshua Morgan

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by vallin21

Yes, but neither has Royal since 2008... Not saying he's a bad player because he did have that 1 great '08 rookie year, but IMO he's not a better return specialist, and he's not the playmaker Ginn is after he catches the ball... Who's to say Ginn wouldn't have the same or better production than Royal? You could also say Shanahan's scheme/system is why Royal had that great rookie yr.

To be fair to Royal, he has had Tebow throwing him the ball the last 2 years. I would prefer him to Ginn, who is just a returner to me.