Around the NFL week 10

[Bishop Hammer]

Originally Posted by Mechanix544

I still say RG3 will have the better career. Just not with the Shanahans.

If RGIII was with Indy they would be just as good or even better. Our teams qb isn't the problem its the coaching staff. Griffin can hit a lot of the throws Luck makes and can read defenses very well(that is an area where Luck is head and shoulders above our guy but that's about it).

Luck has been playing in a pro style offense for four years. On top of having a dad who played in the NFL before. Roberts had none of those advantages. Despite that Andrew just now playing better than our QB. And only by a small margin.

Now the question is would Luck still look just as good here with the Skins current roster? I think not. The fact that Griffin has looked so good with no recievers and a shoddy O line says wonders about his skill set and talent.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by Bishop Hammer

Now the question is would Luck still look just as good here with the Skins current roster? I think not. The fact that Griffin has looked so good with no recievers and a shoddy O line says wonders about his skill set and talent.

I disagree, Luck would just as successful with the Redskins as with the Colts. The Steelers figured a way to contain RGIII and Carolina copied Pittsburgh's strategy. Luck is ahead of the curve playing in the pocket due to his experience in a pro style offense, RGIII is learning very quickly but not there yet. The Shanahan's have the cuffs on RGIII while Luck has free reign, the Colts offense has been on the field longer than their D, that is why they are winning games. The 3 games the Redskins won was due to their Offense controlling the game. RGIII hasn't been helped by injuries to Garcon, Davis, Helu and lots of dropped balls by the WR's.