Pete Prisco the idiot

[Bill B]

Below is Pete Prisco's take on Art Monk getting in over Andre Reed. Prisco left off that Reed had zero Supre Bowl Rings while Monk had 3.

"Those two failed to get selected to the Hall on Saturday, as six other men beat them out. Dent was a better player than fellow end Fred Dean, who did get elected. Reed was a better player than Art Monk, a receiver who also was part of the 2008 six-man class.
Monk retired as the leading all-time receiver in 1995 with 940 catches, but Reed retired with 951. Reed had 87 touchdown catches, while Monk had 68. Reed averaged 13.9 per catch to Monk's 13.5 per catch.
So who deserved it more?"

Prisco's Points - CBSSports.com

[SCRedskinsFan]

He also left out that Art Monk is in the Hall of Fame! lol

[scowan]

If Reed was so good, he should have caught a Superbowl winning TD! Monk has 3 Rings! AND had the single season Recieption record of 108 at one time, before teams passed 80% of the time!

[That Guy]

boo hoo, hopefully he appreciates crying about it for the next 8 years. jerk.

[FRPLG]

Didn't Carter say Monk shouldn't be in the HOF?

[GMScud]

Eat shit Prisco. He's a moron. Obviously.

[redskinmania]

The real question is who picks these idiots who vote.

[pg86]

Fuck Prisco...that asshole probably believes that Rich Gannon should be in the Hall of Fame, or somebody like Wade Wilson should be in...

Now its not often that a skins fan can do this to someone with the cowboys out there having 5 of these but...3 rings bitch 3 rings!!!!!! How many did Carter,Reed, or the Bills have at all?

and even if my history is a little shakey, but aren't the bills that Reed played for the same team that went to the superbowl not once not twice not even 3 times but 4 times AND LOST ALL 4 DAMN TIMES...yeah Shut up Prisco just shut the FUCK up.
If reed was so great...why in the hell didn't he ever help his team to win the superbowl...he ONLY had 4 chances to do so.

BTW I don't recall Reed being able to crack a defender like monk could Monk was one of those recivers that could pancake the shit out of someone on a run

Don't go away mad...just go away..

[squrrelco3]

Guys...guys...guys...

who cares what anyone else thinks

Monk's in

justice has been served

ssssssssswwwwwwweeeeeeeeeeet!!!

[shallyshal]

Originally Posted by Bill B

Below is Pete Prisco's take on Art Monk getting in over Andre Reed. Prisco left off that Reed had zero Supre Bowl Rings while Monk had 3.

"Those two failed to get selected to the Hall on Saturday, as six other men beat them out. Dent was a better player than fellow end Fred Dean, who did get elected. Reed was a better player than Art Monk, a receiver who also was part of the 2008 six-man class.
Monk retired as the leading all-time receiver in 1995 with 940 catches, but Reed retired with 951. Reed had 87 touchdown catches, while Monk had 68. Reed averaged 13.9 per catch to Monk's 13.5 per catch.
So who deserved it more?"

Prisco's Points - CBSSports.com

reed is ALSO worthy of the HOF

i hope he gets in next year. there is no reason why an injustice should be done to reed just because one was done to monk for 7 years

[Daseal]

I'm with Shally. Andre Reed was a stud, no denying it. His stats are great. Personally, I don't feel championships should have a ton of bearing on an individuals bid to the HOF. Football is a team sport, even if you have the best player ever in football, that doesn't guarantee you a super bowl ring.

Both players are great and deserving of the HOF.

[djnemo65]

Reed will get his day, and deservedly so, but this year is all about MONK BABY!

[724Skinsfan]

1) Prisco is an idiot.
2) Reed was a 'Skin and deserves to be in asap.

[#56fanatic]

he brings valid points to the arguement for the sake of "numbers". However, had Monk been elected when he should have been this wouldn't even have been a debate. Monk deserved to get in 7 years ago.

I usually dont bash writers on here, as they have these jobs because they are good at what they do, but where was this arguement when Irvin was elected prior to Monk?? no one really, outside of Redskin nation, really spoke up for Monk until the last year or so when all the Redskin reports and beat writers started making a stink about it.

[scafuri27]

Kevin Greene 160 careeer sacks 3rd all time not in..Andre Tippet 100 in... Reed has 11 more grabs than Monk and Prisco is bitching?? Reed didnt get shafted 8 years in a row liek Monk.. Monk the definition of a team player..3 rings with 3 seperate QB's... there are much larger disparities between people who are in the hall and are not.. Monk trumped all of Irvins stats last season when he got in.. Reed will eventually get in but that should in no way be associated with Monk getting in this year..