Andy Reid or Mike Shanahan? Eagles President takes shot at Shanny

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

All those coaches had great drafts, and from those drafts they built strong teams. It wasn't just about the QB's. So with that being said, let's hope that the guy in charge doesn't throw away picks for an aging inaccurate QB and injured 29 year old tackle. You didn't see any of those guys above doing what Shanahan did. Did you?

Like I said, I'm not sold on Shanny. But he won multiple Super Bowls with a great QB, just like those other coaches.

All those other coaches also had GM's drafting for them.

My point was it's not really fair to take anything away from Shanny because he had Elway. To do so, you'd have to say the same for those other coaches. Shanahan has his shortcomings to be sure, but he still hoisted the Lombardi trophy twice.

I worry a lot more about him as the head of personnel than I do as a HC.