Titans vs. Skins Positives and Negatives.

[Lotus]

Polumbus is not bad as a run blocker. It's only as a pass blocker that he is an utter disaster.

To me, Compton is the real problem. We brought Polumbus in as a stopgap until Compton got ready. Compton should have sent Polumbus to the bench long ago.

Polumbus' failures are Compton's failures.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Polumbus is not bad as a run blocker. It's only as a pass blocker that he is an utter disaster.

To me, Compton is the real problem. We brought Polumbus in as a stopgap until Compton got ready. Compton should have sent Polumbus to the bench long ago.

Polumbus' failures are Compton's failures.

Our Oline drafting are the FO continued failures

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Our Oline drafting are the FO continued failures

True dat.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Polumbus is not bad as a run blocker. It's only as a pass blocker that he is an utter disaster.

To me, Compton is the real problem. We brought Polumbus in as a stopgap until Compton got ready. Compton should have sent Polumbus to the bench long ago.

Polumbus' failures are Compton's failures.

As to Polumbus, last year I would have agreed with you. This year, I have seen too many failures to seal the back end, too many failures to move his man of the spot when the play came his way, and too many holding calls/offsides on run-plays. The reason he was acceptable in the past was that he was competent on run plays. Perhaps that was due to scheme or better blocking from WR/TE/RB's, bottom line is that - this year - he has not even been competent in the run game.

As to Compton being the problem, maybe. This is his 4th year. He was a 6th round pick and was going to be a project no matter what. At this point, put him in - sink or swim.

As to the draft, again not disagreeing:
2014: 2 drafted, 3rd Round. Both regular inactives.
2013: None drafted.
2012: 3 drafted, LeRib (3rd) active but non-starting -unable to displace either Chester or Luavo; Gettis (5th) Steelers Practice Squad; Compton (6th) regular back-up, possible starter later this year.
2011: 1 drafted; Maurice Hurt (7th) Out Of Football
2010: 3 drafted; T.Williams(1st) pro-bowler; Eric Cook (5th) OOF; Selvish Capers (7th) OOF.


Total Picks 2010 - 2014: 42 (3:1st, 3:2nd, 5:3rd, 6:4th, 6:5th, 7:6th, 12:7th)
Total O-Line Picks 2010-2014: 9 (1:1st, 3:3rd, 2:5th, 2:6th, 1:7th)

One starter; two back-ups (LeRib, Compton); two rookies.

Not a lot of development despite 20% of the draft picks since 2010 being spent on O-line. If Moses and Long develop, that would go a long way to mediating that failure.

[Lotus]

Great post Joe. Who can forget the great Selvish Capers?

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Great post Joe. Who can forget the great Selvish Capers?

Heck I forgot that Jim Mora Jr was the Seahawks coach after Mike Holmgren left.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Great post Joe. Who can forget the great Selvish Capers?

I had really high hopes for the guy as a converted TE. He had a mid-round grade and looked like he might be a steal. Thought he might make an athletic RT. Oh well.

He stuck around the league for 5 years (mostly with the NY Giants).

[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by Lotus

Polumbus is not bad as a run blocker. It's only as a pass blocker that he is an utter disaster.

To me, Compton is the real problem. We brought Polumbus in as a stopgap until Compton got ready. Compton should have sent Polumbus to the bench long ago.

Polumbus' failures are Compton's failures.

Compton was/is a 6th round pick. Those guys are drafted to be backups/special teamers. If you get meaningful reps from them as a starter then that's a bonus, not an expectation. Polumbus is a failure of Polumbus and the front office for not replacing him sooner.

If anything, Moses is failing us by not being ready nearly halfway into his rookie season as a 'high' draft pick.

I really wonder about Chris Forester as a line coach. He hasn't developed anyone, our line was an issue when he got here and still is to this day. After 5 years, I don't expect him to start being a better coach.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

Compton was/is a 6th round pick. Those guys are drafted to be backups/special teamers. If you get meaningful reps from them as a starter then that's a bonus, not an expectation. Polumbus is a failure of Polumbus and the front office for not replacing him sooner.

If anything, Moses is failing us by not being ready nearly halfway into his rookie season as a 'high' draft pick.

I really wonder about Chris Forester as a line coach. He hasn't developed anyone, our line was an issue when he got here and still is to this day. After 5 years, I don't expect him to start being a better coach.

To your point, I think fans forget guys like Jacoby (UDFA), Schlereth (12th round), McKenzie (11th round) were not high draft picks. With the exception of 1981, the Redskins did not invest much in high draft picks for the OL during Gibbs 1.0. And when they did it was often disastrous (Andre Collins). So yeah maybe we need to look at who's coaching these guys

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

To your point, I think fans forget guys like Jacoby (UDFA), Schlereth (12th round), McKenzie (11th round) were not high draft picks. With the exception of 1981, the Redskins did not invest much in high draft picks for the OL during Gibbs 1.0. And when they did it was often disastrous (Andre Collins). So yeah maybe we need to look at who's coaching these guys

It's Jim Haslett's fault.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

To your point, I think fans forget guys like Jacoby (UDFA), Schlereth (12th round), McKenzie (11th round) were not high draft picks. With the exception of 1981, the Redskins did not invest much in high draft picks for the OL during Gibbs 1.0. And when they did it was often disastrous (Andre Collins). So yeah maybe we need to look at who's coaching these guys

From 1982 to 1992, we drafted (in a 12 round draft) 17 linemen. Of those only 7 were picked before the 7th round. One 2nd rounder (Wally Klein, '87), two 3rd rounders (Mo Elewonibi, '90; Paul Sevier, 92). Four 6th rounders - of whom only Ed Simmons stuck around (and he did for 10 years).

In fact, in '91, the Skins did not draft an o-lineman out of nine picks.

It was a different era, but still, we have invested significantly more in drafting o-linemen over the last 5 years than we did during the ten year reign of the Hogs with much less to show for it.

[TheMalcolmConnection]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

From 1982 to 1992, we drafted (in a 12 round draft) 17 linemen. Of those only 7 were picked before the 7th round. One 2nd rounder (Wally Klein, '87), two 3rd rounders (Mo Elewonibi, '90; Paul Sevier, 92). Four 6th rounders - of whom only Ed Simmons stuck around (and he did for 10 years).

In fact, in '91, the Skins did not draft an o-lineman out of nine picks.

It was a different era, but still, we have invested significantly more in drafting o-linemen over the last 5 years than we did during the ten year reign of the Hogs with much less to show for it.

In the end it's just not letting these guys see the field. You'll never know what you have until you do. I feel like we've constantly had these 3-5th round picks on the bench until we sign some mediocre/big name FA, they flounder on the bench, get cut, start somewhere else. Now they're not Pro Bowlers, but I think we've had a few get cut that went on to start for some good teams.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

To your point, I think fans forget guys like Jacoby (UDFA), Schlereth (12th round), McKenzie (11th round) were not high draft picks. With the exception of 1981, the Redskins did not invest much in high draft picks for the OL during Gibbs 1.0. And when they did it was often disastrous (Andre Collins). So yeah maybe we need to look at who's coaching these guys

Andre Collins was a disaster at the tackle position. Mainly b/c he was a LB (an a relatively solid one at that) drafted in the 2nd round in 1990.

Perhaps you meant Andre Johnson out of Penn State in '96, drafted by Casserly during Norv Turner's stellar regime? At least you got the "disaster" part right.

You would think someone from "the Media" would at least fact check.

... and now you know why no one trusts ESPN.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

Andre Collins was a disaster at the tackle position. Mainly b/c he was a LB (an a relatively solid one at that) drafted in the 2nd round in 1990.

Perhaps you meant Andre Johnson out of Penn State in '96, drafted by Casserly during Norv Turner's stellar regime? At least you got the "disaster" part right.

You would think someone from "the Media" would at least fact check.

... and now you know why no one trusts ESPN.

LOL. Whoops. Blame my time at SB Nation for that one